Grade level and subjects
• Recommended for grades 6-12
• Subjects: Government
• Works in Classroom, Hybrid, and Homeschool settings
What students will learn
By the end of this lesson, students will be able to:
• summarize the reasons the speakers in the video give for why debate matters to a free society;
• distinguish between arguments supported by evidence and appeals to emotion;
• construct an argument for an assigned side, using evidence and answering the other side’s best points; and
• evaluate who, if anyone, should decide which ideas are too harmful to debate.
Key concepts and terms covered
Assigned Side, Censorship, Civil Discourse, Claim, Critical Thinking, Empathy, Evidence, Free Speech, Moderator, Persuasion, Rebuttal, Round Table, and Steelman.
Sample discussion questions
• How were the debaters’ sides decided?
• Why does Michael Shellenberger want bad ideas said out loud?
• How could arguing an assigned side make someone a better thinker?
• Robby Soave asks, “Who gets to decide what is harmful?” How would you answer him?
• Lou Perez says that when someone tries to shut down a debate, we should ask, “Why don’t they want to talk about this?” Are there ever good reasons to refuse to debate something? Explain.
What’s in the free teacher’s guide
This printable 22-page Teacher’s Guide includes a lesson description, learning objectives, key vocabulary, a fill-in viewing guide with answer key, discussion and analysis questions, classroom activities, and the full video transcript.
Related resources
• America: Founded on Debate — The companion video in the Death of Debate series. John Papola and Jay Heinrichs trace America’s history as a long public argument, from John Adams’s defense of the British soldiers to the Kennedy-Nixon debate.
• The Power of Debate — John Stossel on the need for debate and the power of free speech.
• Speech for Me, Not for Thee — John Stossel looks at how politicians from both major parties, once in power, have tried to silence their critics.
• Both Sides: Free Speech — Should there be limits on freedom of speech? Is online speech different from offline speech? A video pairing built for classroom debate.
• Undivide Us — Can Americans who disagree still talk to each other? This video shows civil conversation across differences, and its lesson plan, “In the Other Person’s Shoes,” gives teachers a discussion technique for guiding students through opposing viewpoints on controversial topics.