Overview
What happens when one nation, one people, and one capital city are split down the middle and handed two opposite economic systems? In this video, German historians Rainer Zitelmann and Hubertus Knabe, along with East Germans who lived through it, describe daily life on both sides of the Berlin Wall. Students see how central planning shaped everything from the cars people drove to the air they breathed, while the market economy in the West filled shops and raised living standards. The video closes with the peaceful Monday Protests that brought the Wall down and the prosperity that followed reunification.

Enter your email address below to access these resources

To help ensure our emails reach your inbox, you may provide a personal email address to bypass school spam filters.

Lesson Insights

Grade level and subjects
• Recommended for grades 6-12
• Subjects: Government, Economics, History
• Works in Classroom, Hybrid, and Homeschool settings

What students will learn
By the end of this lesson, students will be able to:
• outline how the Allied division of Germany after World War II placed two opposing economic systems side by side;
• distinguish between a market economy, in which entrepreneurs and consumers decide what is produced, and a planned economy, in which politicians and civil servants decide;
• investigate how central planning in East Germany produced shortages, decaying housing, and severe pollution; and
• argue whether a government can ever justify the methods East Germany used to keep its own citizens from leaving.

Key concepts and terms covered
Berlin Wall, Black Market, Brain Drain, Capitalism, Defector, Market Economy, Parliamentary Republic, Planned Economy, Rent Freeze, Socialism, Standard of Living, Stasi, and Subsidy.

Sample discussion questions
• In a market economy, who decides what gets produced? In a planned economy, who decides? Why does that single difference matter so much?
• Christine and Manfred Schreiber recall that oranges were available only at Christmas, and that a shopkeeper would ask how many children a family had before allowing “maximum six oranges, or three bananas.” What does rationing by the shopkeeper tell you about prices and supply?
• Dr. Hubertus Knabe learned that his best friend, a priest, had been informing on him to the Stasi. What does that story reveal about how surveillance changes the way people treat one another?
• Many people assume capitalism is the greater threat to the environment, yet the video reports that East Germany had the highest per capita air pollution in the world. What explains that result?
• President Reagan told Mikhail Gorbachev to “tear down this wall,” but Gorbachev did not. The video credits the Monday Protests in Leipzig and the chant “We are the people.” What does that suggest about where a government’s power ultimately comes from?

What’s in the free teacher’s guide
This printable 28-page Teacher’s Guide includes a lesson description, learning objectives, key vocabulary, a fill-in viewing guide with answer key, discussion and analysis questions, classroom activities, and the full video transcript.

Related resources
• Equal Shares – Why Collectivism Fails — Traces real collectivist experiments, from New Harmony, Indiana, to Israeli kibbutzim, and finds that the communities that survived did so by embracing private property. A direct companion for the video’s contrast between planned and market economies.
• 5 Socialism Myths, Part 1 — Takes on the most common misconceptions about socialism and tests them against the historical record. Extends the East German case into a broader look at the claims made for socialism.
• The Case for Capitalism — John Stossel, with Steve Forbes and Thomas Sowell, shows how voluntary exchange creates wealth and why the fixed-pie idea is mistaken. A natural counterpart to the West German market economy shown in this video.
• Nothing to Hide – The Privacy Myth — Examines how being watched changes what people are willing to say and do — a natural companion to the video’s account of the Stasi and daily life under constant surveillance.
• The Grade Experiment — Follows a classroom where individual grades are replaced with a class average, letting students feel firsthand how equal outcomes affect effort. A classroom-friendly way to explore why East Germany’s planned system sapped incentives.